Main Course

Homemade Pepperoni Pizza with 48-Hour Neapolitan-Style Dough

Total timeTotal
2 days
ServingsServings
2-4

This recipe for homemade pepperoni pizza will make you change your mind about homemade pizza! With Neapolitan-style pizza dough, a light tomato sauce and professional-level baking on a pizza stone or steel, success is guaranteed!

Homemade Pepperoni Pizza with 48-Hour Neapolitan-Style Dough

This recipe for homemade pepperoni pizza will make you change your mind about homemade pizza! With Neapolitan-style pizza dough, a light tomato sauce and professional-level baking on a pizza stone or steel, success is guaranteed!

Personally, I had tried many baking alternatives without success, such as baking on an upside-down baking tray in the oven and various other “hacks” found on the Internet. A pizza stone or steel helped me focus on the pizza dough, the pizza sauce alternatives and, of course, the different pizza flavors with my favorite ingredients.

That's how I arrived at the recipe below for homemade pepperoni pizza!

Step by step

1 photo
Pizza dough
Step 8 · Pizza dough
The recipe

Homemade Pepperoni Pizza with 48-Hour Neapolitan-Style Dough Recipe

Total time 2 days · 2-4 servings

Ingredients

For the pizza dough

For the pizza sauce

For the rest

Method

  1. Preparing the pizza dough

  2. Make the pizza dough 2 days before you need it, because ideally we want to let it mature for 48 hours for the best result.
  3. First, pour the water into the bowl of a mixer or a large bowl, add the dry yeast, stir and let it activate for a few minutes.
  4. Once bubbles appear on the surface of the water, add a few spoonfuls of the flour and mix with the dough hook of the mixer or with a ladle.
  5. When the flour has been incorporated into the water, add the salt and a little more flour, continuing to mix.
  6. Repeat the process until all the flour is incorporated and the pizza dough takes shape.
  7. Knead for 10 minutes until you have an even dough.
  8. Flour the kitchen counter and knead the pizza dough by hand for another 5 minutes, until it becomes elastic.
  9. Shape it into a ball, place it in a large bowl lightly greased with olive oil and cover it very well with plastic wrap or a lid so that no air gets in.
  10. Maturing the pizza dough

  11. Place the bowl in the fridge and let the pizza dough mature for 48 hours.
  12. Alternatively, divide the dough into 4 equal parts and place each one in a smaller container.
  13. TipAlternatively, you can use airtight zip-top plastic bags.
  14. Take the dough out of the fridge 3 hours before making the pizza, knead it for 2 minutes and shape 4 equal dough balls.
  15. Flour a baking tray, place the dough balls on it with space between them and cover with plastic wrap.
  16. Let the pizza dough rise for about 3 hours, until the balls have doubled in volume.
  17. TipIf you don’t have time for the 48-hour maturing, you can shape the 4 balls and let them double using the process above. The result will be good, but the dough won’t be as elastic to stretch.
  18. Preparing the pizza sauce

  19. Open the can of whole tomatoes, add the salt and a little pepper and puree well with an immersion blender.
  20. Preparing the oven

  21. Place the pizza stone or steel on the oven rack, in the 2nd position from the top, and heat the oven’s heating elements at maximum temperature for 45 minutes.
  22. Ideally, measure the temperature of the stone or steel with a digital infrared thermometer so that it reaches about 320°C.
  23. Final steps

  24. Flour a wide spatula and carefully lift one dough ball without ruining its shape and without pressing the air out of it.
  25. Place the dough on a well-floured surface and sprinkle a little extra flour on top.
  26. Stretch the pizza dough by pressing with your fingers from the center outward.
  27. Slowly rotate the pizza and repeat the process until the pizza is stretched and a “ring” forms around it.
  28. Don’t stretch the dough with a rolling pin, because all the air trapped inside will escape and no bubbles will form while the pizza bakes.
  29. The diameter of the pizza should be between 25 and 30 cm, depending on the thickness you want.
  30. Sprinkle a little fine semolina on the pizza peel so the dough doesn’t stick, and place the stretched dough on top.
  31. Spread 3 tbsp of tomato sauce (70 g) in circular motions with the back of a large spoon, leaving a 1–2 cm border all around.
  32. Add the grated mozzarella on top and finally the slices of pepperoni.
  33. Turn on the oven’s broiler and carefully transfer the pizza onto the hot stone or steel.
  34. Bake the pizza for about 4 minutes, or until it reaches the color you want.
  35. TipIf your oven is very powerful and reaches 300–350°C, the heating elements may be enough and you won’t need the broiler. You’ll need a few tries the first times.
  36. TipMany home ovens top out at 500–550°F (260–290°C). If yours does, use its highest setting and preheat the pizza stone or steel for the full 45 minutes.
  37. Remove the homemade pepperoni pizza from the oven, place it on a rack for 1 minute, then cut it into pieces and serve.

Did you make it?

Tell us how it turned out, with one click.

Be one of the first to rate it.

Reader ratings, Greek and English versions. How we check

Homemade pepperoni pizza
  1. Greek Cabbage Rolls with Pork and Chestnuts (Lahanodolmades)
  2. Greek Christmas Rice with Pine Nuts, Pomegranate and Pistachios
  3. Turkey Wellington with Chestnuts and Cranberries
  4. Turkey Wellington with Gorgonzola and Mushrooms
All 31 recipes →

@alwayshungry.gr

Follow on Instagram ↗